Menu
Upward Trek

A Theological Dumpster Fire: What’s Happening to the Church?

By Pete Garcia

Modern Christendom has devolved into a theological dumpster fire when it comes to doctrines. I have zero doubt that Satan and his minions have been hard at work to exacerbate the divisions, to keep the church weakened and less effective.

Mind-boggling it is, to literally see Bible prophecy being fulfilled, with the rebirth of national Israel, technological and geopolitical convergence towards the world of Revelation 13, cultural and societal decay, and Christians running around saying “we can’t know anything” or “the church has to conquer the world first,” or the rest of the following nonsense:

 

1. “We are in the Kingdom now.”

Wow, if true, the Bible completely oversold this whole concept.

 

2. “All prophecies were fulfilled by AD70.”

Hmmm…that doesn’t seem to line up with Jeremiah 30:7-11, Zech 12, 14:4, Luke 21:24, Revelation 13, etc.

 

3. “There is no Rapture!”

Really, so why does the apostle Paul, whom Christ appointed and taught, and who was recognized by the other apostles, describe a resurrection of the dead church-age saints and a physical, bodily translation of the living into their glorified, immortal bodies that has 20-30 distinct differences from the Second Coming?

Key Scriptures: 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18; 1 Cor 15:51-55

 

4. “Bible prophecy is not important.” (or similar sentiment)

All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness…” 2 Tim 3:16.

Since when did “ALL” only mean some? And since prophecy makes up more than a 1/3 of the Bible, and it’s placed throughout it from Genesis to Revelation, and by ignoring it, one is severely handicapping one’s understanding of the Bible in its totality, it seems pretty important.

 

5. “I don’t study prophecy; I just focus on Jesus.” (I had a pastor actually tell me this verbatim).

“…Worship God! For the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” Revelation 19:10

If someone really wants to know Jesus, they will study prophecy since it’s all about Jesus. (See also Luke 24:27)

 

6. “We are in Satan’s little season now!”

Ummm…interesting. This smells like preterism.

• When did the 70th Week of Daniel happen?

• When did Christ destroy all the nations of the earth?

• When did the Second Coming happen?

• When did the Millennial Kingdom happen?

I could go on.

Key Scriptures: Jer 30:7-11, Dan 7:25, 12:7, 9:27; Matt 24:15; 2 Thess. 2:4, Rev. 11:2

 

7. “Revelation is just apocalyptic literature. You’re not supposed to interpret it literally.”

Apocalyptic literature uses symbols, but symbols can represent real people, kingdoms, events, and judgments. Daniel’s symbolic visions, for example, describe actual historical empires. Revelation builds on these same symbols (ex Rev 13). The immediate context (surrounding passages) or other Scripture warrants whether a symbolic interpretation is necessary or not.

From a dispensational, grammatical-historical hermeneutic, the book of Revelation is a unique combination of prophecy, epistle, and apocalyptic revelation, and its prophetic identity must govern how its symbols are interpreted.

Key Scriptures: Dan 2:36–45; 7:17, 23; Rev 1:20; 17:9–12.

 

8. “The Church has replaced Israel.”

Romans 11 explicitly addresses Israel’s unbelief, the inclusion of Gentiles, and the reality of Israel’s future restoration.

Paul’s declaration that “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” provides an important basis for arguing that God’s covenant commitments to Israel have not been canceled.

Key Scriptures: Romans 9–11, especially 11:25–29; Jer 31:35–37.

 

9. “There is no distinction between Israel and the Church.”

Jews and Gentiles are united in Christ regarding salvation, but spiritual equality does not eliminate the unconditional national covenant promises God made to Israel.

Key Scriptures: Eph 2:11–22; Romans 11:1–2, 25–29; Acts 1:6–7.

 

10. “All the Old Testament promises were spiritually fulfilled in Christ.”

Christ is the fulfillment and center of biblical prophecy (Luke 24:21, Rev 19:10). However, Dan 9:24 lists six things that MUST be fulfilled, and clearly, they haven’t all yet.

For example, Gabriel promised Jesus David’s throne and a future reign over the house of Jacob.

Key Scriptures: 2 Sam 7, Luke 1:31–33, 24:27; Jer 23:5–8; Acts 1:6–7.

 

11. “The Church must go through the Tribulation to be purified.”

Scripture teaches that believers experience trials and tribulations from the first century until now. This is the wrath of man, whether it’s persecution, martyrdom, censorship, segregation, oppression, or suppression. That does not mean the Church must undergo the specific period of divine judgment described in Revelation set aside for the world and Israel, aka, “The Tribulation” or Daniel’s 70th Week.

Only the pretribulational argument distinguishes the sanctifying trials of believers from the eschatological outpouring of God’s wrath.

Key Scriptures: John 15:18, 16:33, 17:15; Romans 5:1–5; 1 Thess 1:10, 5:9; Rev 3:10.

 

12. “The word ‘Rapture’ isn’t in the Bible.”

The English word is derived from the Latin for “catching up” in 1 Thessalonians 4:17. The Greek verb is harpazō, meaning to seize, snatch, or catch away.

The theological concept is more important than whether the English label appears in a particular translation.

Key Scriptures: 1 Thess 4:16–17; 1 Cor 15:51–53.

Relevant uses

• Acts 8:39 — Philip’s supernatural transportation

Philip is suddenly carried away by the Spirit of the Lord after baptizing the Ethiopian eunuch. This demonstrates that harpazō can describe supernatural relocation.

• 2 Corinthians 12:2 — Caught up to the third heaven

Paul describes a man (himself) caught up into heaven, although he explicitly says he does not know whether the experience was bodily or out of the body.

• 2 Corinthians 12:4 — Caught up into Paradise

Paul repeats the verb in describing the same heavenly experience.

• 1 Thessalonians 4:17 — The catching away of the Church

Living believers are caught up together with resurrected believers to meet the Lord in the air. This is the clearest passage connecting harpazō to the future gathering of the Church.

• Revelation 12:5 — The male Child caught up to God

In the common messianic interpretation, this refers to Christ’s exaltation to God’s throne, presented in a compressed prophetic vision.

Honorable mentions: Enoch and Elijah; neither man saw death but was caught up/translated to God.

 

Pete Garcia

No Comments

    Leave a Reply